The Mozart Effect

April 29th, 2008

Mozart Mice

By Ryan Malone

Can Mozart make you smarter? Well, that’s what researchers at the University of California-Irvine asked back in 1993. The answer?

Frances Rauscher, Gordon Shaw and Katherine Ky gave preschool and college students standard tests of spatial reasoning (being able to turn an object in one’s head or to imagine how pieces of a shape fit together). The tests were given after the students had experienced three different conditions for ten minutes: one condition was silence, one was listening to a relaxation tape, another was listening to Mozart’s Sonata for Two Pianos in D Major. Performance on the post-Mozart spatial tests were significantly better.

But, of course, not all scientific experiments are reliable. Every experiment must be proven over and over before it can be accepted as fact. So in 1994, researchers at the University of Auckland examined the effects of listening to Mozart contrasted with other types of music or silence. Seventy-nine college students were divided into three groups. One group listened to Mozart (the same piece used in the ’93 study). Another listened to silence. The third group listened to a piece by Philip Glass—a composer of music based on endless repetitions of patterns. The two latter groups showed no significant increase in spatial IQ. But the Mozart group did!

In further studies, researchers found that listening to a taped short story or to dance music did not enhance test scores.

Rauscher, Shaw and Ky originally chose Mozart because they thought that the highly structured music he wrote would enhance brain processing, whereas less complex or highly repetitive music would interfere with abstract reasoning. (Other researchers are anxious to try the experiment with other classical composers.)

The Irvine scientists also found that rats exposed to the same Mozart piece learned to run mazes faster and with fewer errors compared with genetically identical animals exposed to other sounds. The Mozart rodents averaged a 35-second maze run. Those listening merely to white noise (like TV static) ran the maze in 44 seconds. And Philip Glass’ rats? It took them 50 seconds. Purely from a learning standpoint, the Mozartian mice also learned the right route through the maze more quickly than the others.

All this confirms research that has stated a strong connection between the part of the brain that is “wired” for music perception and that for spatial tasks. This wiring—or forming of neural connections—begins early in life. Oddly enough, most students felt the “Mozart effect” only for about 10 to 15 minutes, yet it lasted longer in those who had some musical training.

This was part of the rodent experiment as well: Some of the rats were exposed to Mozart while in the womb and every night for the first 60 days of their life. They “apparently had changes in their neural machinery that persisted hours after their last dose of Mozart” (Chicago Tribune, Aug. 11, 1998).

There is much research out there telling you what type of music has damaging effects to the mind and the ears—what you should not listen to. But here is something you can listen to. Not only does this music not contain “harmful side effects,” it may actually produce good results for your developing mind. And if you’ve played an instrument since childhood, your brain is already primed to feel the effects of Mozart’s music.

Even though we’ve discussed several instances where the “Mozart effect” seemed to produce good results, some scientists have had trouble duplicating the results. Although it is still a matter of some controversy, realize that it cannot hurt you to listen to Mozart. It has certainly helped some. All the benefits from widening your musical vocabulary may not even be scientifically measurable.

So put Mozart to the test. And see if his music makes you any smarter.

Listen to This!

Here are some particularly good representations of Mozart’s music that you might try (aside from the much acclaimed “Sonata for Two Pianos in D Major,”K. 448, used in the experiment):

Symphonies: No. 25 in G Minor; No. 35 in D; No. 40 in G Minor; No. 41 in C.

Choral Works: The Great Mass in C Minor (K. 427); Requiem Mass in D Minor.

Piano Concerti: No. 9 in E-flat; No. 20 in D Minor; No. 21 in C; No. 26 in D; No. 27 in B-flat.

Operas:The Marriage of Figaro; Don Giovanni;The Magic Flute.

Other: Serenade No. 11 for Winds in E-flat; Violin Concerti Nos. 3 and 5.

6 Responses to “The Mozart Effect”

  1. Melonie Holmes Says:

    Very interesting. iTunes has an album “Mozart for your mind” which I have downloaded. It has many of the music you mention. Eventhough science is inconclusive about this, it would seem logical that music could affect learning since it affects moods too. Also God places so much emphasis on music. I think the print edition of the True Ed had a great article on music some time ago. It would be great to see that on the web edition. Thanks for this article!

  2. Yang-Ming Goh Says:

    That’s interesting because when i was in grade 3 my teacher put on Mozart for us to listen to while we were doing work. She said it would help us work, but most of my class didn’t believe that. Thanks for the great article.

  3. Jinnie Monsalve Says:

    I think this would be interesting to try this week in my school. We are having state testing. I think it will help us concentrate.

  4. Jerry Ozipko Says:

    Another great article. However, in your supplementary listening list you inadvertently omitted a work which many music critics believe to be the most perfect concerto ever written for any instrument –and it contains the only known cadenzas actually composed by Mozart — namely, the Sinfonia Concertante in E-flat for Violin, Viola and Orchestra, K.V. 364. It’s a delight to the ears. Keep on enlightening the youth with such worthwhile activities.

  5. Suzanne Bigsby Says:

    There’s a lot to this! I play classical music each morning for my students from 7:30 - 8:00. It helps them relax and focus for the day. I also play it for testing to help them access information and again during writers workshop. There’s some whining at the first of the year, but by October they ask for “my music” and say they can’t concentrate without it.
    Of course, I play bluegrass and oldies to get them cranked up. Music will absolutely impact learners. Try it, guys!

  6. Anna Padua Says:

    This is really great. At long last i’ve been able to find this article. One of my councilors from last year’s youth camp here in the Philippines told me about this article to help me with my speech. It has really been a wonderful addition to make the speech very informative. Thank you! It’s also fantastic that you’ve put some of Mozart’s musical representations here for us to try to listen to.

Leave a Reply